Private Photo Vault documents encrypted local files and optional Cloud Vault backup. Photo Vault offers a local imported-media gallery whose new and successfully migrated archives use encryption with a device-only installation key. The two products also have different recovery models, so do not choose by their similar names.
Identify the product first
This comparison concerns Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe by Legendary Software Labs LLC (App Store ID 417571834), linked from privatephotovault.com, and our Photo Vault preview at source commit d68c41e. They are separate products. Check the developer before following recovery instructions or granting photo access.
A separate Cybernews investigation describes an app called Photo Vault by Brain Craft. Its disclosure timeline runs from January to February 2025, and the report says database access was secured after disclosure. That report concerns the named Brain Craft product; it should not be attributed to Legendary Software Labs or Arte Soft because of a similar app name.
PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress 1.0 is live on the App Store for iPhone and iPad; always test your own import, export, and backup workflow before deleting originals. Archive encryption applies to new archives and successful migrations; the installation key is device-only, and final-build migration, export and recovery checks remain pending.
Compare the documented boundaries
| Question | Private Photo Vault documentation | Photo Vault preview |
|---|---|---|
| Local media | States AES-encrypted file storage. | Media stored without app-level encryption. |
| Account for local storage | Vendor says local encrypted storage works offline without an account. | No Photo Vault account or gallery-upload server. |
| Cloud option | Optional premium Cloud Vault. | No app-managed cloud sync or backup service. |
| Cloud setup | Requires Premium, an account, internet and completed uploads. Installation alone does not enable it. | No equivalent app cloud service. |
| Cloud recovery secret | Separate Cloud Vault password. | No equivalent Cloud Vault service. |
| Gallery access | Separate app credential, with documented recovery conditions. | Password, pattern or device authentication. |
| Before retiring a phone | Verify a usable backup and destination files. | Export and verify independent copies; archive restore unverified. |
| Extra lock features | Vendor documents a decoy and, on supported Apple devices, combined Face ID and vault PIN. | One selected method: password, pattern or device authentication; no decoy. |
Keep access and recovery separate
Private Photo Vault’s FAQ distinguishes app or album password recovery by a previously configured email from its unrecoverable Cloud Vault password. That distinction matters when replacing a phone: regaining access to one screen does not establish that you possess the secret needed for a different copy.
Run a transfer trial before choosing
Import a replaceable photo and a video, close and reopen the app, then export the files to a destination you control. Inspect detail, duration and sound. If you need cloud recovery, complete a supported test with a separate device while retaining the original. Keep a record of which password applies to each step.
Where Photo Vault can fit
Photo Vault is being developed as a separate local gallery. Its app credential is separate from the device-bound installation key protecting the archive. New Photo Vault Lossy imports store compressed media and separate encrypted metadata without whole source files. Still photos export as reconstructed JPEG or PNG files; existing retained originals keep their export path. This is not a tested release or evidence of a security upgrade over Private Photo Vault’s documented encryption model.
Storage savings and original files
Private Photo Vault advertises Space Saver with originals in Cloud Vault. Photo Vault has no equivalent cloud library: new Lossy imports use compressed media and separate encrypted metadata without whole source files. Existing retained originals remain exportable. Identify where each original lives and verify independently recoverable copies. Photo Vault’s ZIP and sharing functions remain in progress.
What this comparison does not prove
We have not audited Private Photo Vault’s shipped app, key lifecycle or cloud service, or measured its performance. Its security statements remain vendor claims. Current plan prices and storefront offers need checking separately. This comparison is written by Photo Vault’s developer and makes no independent security rating.
Sources & further reading
- Private Photo Vault: product security documentation
- Private Photo Vault: password and backup FAQ
- Private Photo Vault: Cloud Vault encryption
- App Store: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe, Legendary Software Labs LLC
- Private Photo Vault: Space Saver and feature availability
- Cybernews: investigation identifying Photo Vault by Brain Craft