Use Hidden Album to keep selected items out of everyday Photos views within the same library. PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress provides a separate gallery with its own app credential and an encrypted archive retaining selected original resources. Its device-bound archive key is separate from that credential; export and recovery should be verified with a test export on your device.
Different jobs, different trade-offs
Hiding changes where an item appears within Apple Photos. Importing into Photo Vault creates an archive copy outside that library. Neither action automatically removes copies already shared with other people. Choosing a second app also creates a second place you must maintain, export and protect against loss.
PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress 1.0 is live on the App Store for iPhone and iPad; always test your own import, export, and backup workflow before deleting originals. Archive encryption applies to new archives and successful migrations; the installation key is device-only, and final-build migration, export and recovery checks remain pending.
Compare the workflow
| Question | Apple Hidden Album | Photo Vault preview |
|---|---|---|
| Where are the items? | Inside the Photos library, in a hidden collection. | Encoded frames and tracks in a local MOV archive. |
| A separate credential? | No separate Hidden Album password. | Password or pattern distinct from device passcode; device authentication is also available. |
| What changes to the file? | Hiding is a visibility change, not our app’s compression step. | New Photo Vault Lossy imports store compressed media and separate encrypted metadata without whole source files. Still photos export as reconstructed JPEG or PNG files; existing retained originals keep their export path. Export and sharing remain unverified. |
| Sync between devices? | Hidden status follows iCloud Photos when enabled. | No app-managed sync. Device backup restoration has not been verified. |
| User-key encryption by Photo Vault? | Not a Photo Vault feature. Apple’s own device and iCloud protections apply. | Not with the app password. New and successfully migrated archives use AES-256-GCM under keys protected by a device-only installation key. |
| Removing originals? | Items remain in the Photos library. | A Photos import can end with a request to delete eligible originals; decline to keep them. |
| Additional purchase? | Built into supported Apple devices. | Release availability and price are not yet verified. |
Finding items in the separate archive
In the reviewed Photo Vault update, gallery search combines filenames, album titles, capture dates and available analysis such as text recognized inside a picture. Hidden and deleted items are excluded from ordinary search results. An empty result does not prove that a file has disappeared: check its visibility, available metadata and whether indexing has finished.
Recognition runs on the device, but place-name indexing can send coordinates to Apple through MapKit while the gallery is active. It does not require opening the map first. This source review does not establish search accuracy or speed on a finished build.
Choose with a small example
If you want ten personal pictures out of the daily grid, begin with Hidden Album and review your device access settings. If your main goal is a separately organised collection, wait for a working Photo Vault build and test a representative import and export before moving more.
Understand the lock around the lock
The Hidden Album lock and an iOS lock on the whole Photos app are separate controls. Stolen Device Protection can remove passcode fallback for opening a locked app under its configured conditions. Do not infer the protection of an entire phone from one lock screen.
When neither choice answers the requirement
If your requirement is files encrypted with a key unavailable to the app maker, evaluate a product that documents that design. If you need exact original files for editing or evidence, keep them independently. Photo Vault’s archive should not be your only copy of irreplaceable material.
Basis of this comparison
Apple-side statements come from the linked documentation. Photo Vault-side statements come from our source review of d68c41e. This is a developer-authored comparison, not an independent security audit or a benchmark of rival software.