# Photo Vault vs Secret Photo Album: local storage or cloud recovery?

> Compare Photo Vault with BPMobile’s Secret Photo Album – SA: storage, recovery, decoy access and what the encryption claims establish.

Canonical page: https://photovault.arte-soft.com/compare/photo-vault-vs-secret-photo-album/

Arte Soft editorial team
Reviewed: 2026-10-20
Modified: 2026-10-20

Choose around the recovery workflow you need. Secret Photo Album – SA advertises encrypted storage and Premium cloud recovery. PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress retains selected original resources and compressed previews in a local encrypted archive. Its installation key is device-bound, and its export and recovery workflow still needs runtime verification. We have not independently verified SA’s encryption implementation.

## Identify the app before comparing

This page covers BPMobile’s Secret Photo Album – SA, sold by BP Mobile LLC, App Store ID 1174964304. Other apps use similar names; match the seller and ID before applying this comparison.

PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress 1.0 is live on the App Store for iPhone and iPad; always test your own import, export, and backup workflow before deleting originals. Archive encryption applies to new archives and successful migrations; the installation key is device-only, and final-build migration, export and recovery checks remain pending.


## Compare the storage workflow


SA developer claims versus Photo Vault source review at d68c41e

| Question | Secret Photo Album – SA | Photo Vault |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Unlock | PIN, Touch ID or Face ID advertised. | Choose one lock method: a Photo Vault password, a pattern, or device authentication. Device authentication can fall back to the iPhone or iPad passcode. |
| Decoy | Decoy PIN advertised. | No decoy gallery. |
| Recovery | Premium cloud sync and restore using email registration. | No app-managed cloud backup or sync. |
| Media encryption | Advertised; key ownership unverified here. | AES-256-GCM for new and successfully migrated archives; device-only installation key, separate from app credential. |
| Archive quality | Original-file preservation not tested here. | New Photo Vault Lossy imports store compressed media and separate encrypted metadata without whole source files. Still photos export as reconstructed JPEG or PNG files; existing retained originals keep their export path. Final export and sharing verification is pending. |

## Cloud recovery and confidentiality answer different questions

A recoverable account does not by itself establish who can decrypt stored files. Ask whether a password reset restores access to existing media, who holds the keys, and whether the publisher has a technical security description. We have not established those answers for SA.

Photo Vault’s app lock restricts access through its interface. It does not turn the underlying media archive into encrypted storage. If protection of copied media files is a requirement, the current Photo Vault implementation does not meet it.


## Test a small collection before moving a library

Keep the originals and import disposable examples: a portrait, a detailed image and a video with sound. Export each and inspect dimensions, visible detail, playback and dates. For a cloud workflow, verify a second-device restore while the original device remains available.

For Photo Vault, measure the complete archive, including retained originals, previews and its index, on your device. A smaller preview is not a storage-saving result. Verify exported resources and independent recovery separately; neither can be inferred from archive size.


## An album PIN is different from an album grouping

SA’s listing advertises an additional PIN for selected albums. Photo Vault’s albums organize references to items in one archive; they do not have separate passwords. Pinning a Photo Vault album makes it easier to reach and does not add an access restriction.

If you need different people to access different collections, test that requirement explicitly rather than assuming an album label provides it. We have not verified SA’s album access rules or whether separate album PINs correspond to separate encryption keys. Photo Vault’s current album behavior is described from source update e27c10f, without a device test.


## Who should evaluate which workflow?

Evaluate SA if cloud recovery or a decoy interface is central to your needs. Treat those as features to test, not guarantees of confidentiality or safety. PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress provides a local encrypted gallery with compressed media, separate metadata and an app lock. New Lossy still images use reconstructed exports; existing retained originals remain exportable. Evaluate storage, export and recovery behavior before relying on it.

Neither a feature list nor this comparison establishes which app is more secure overall. We build Photo Vault and reviewed documentation rather than installing or auditing SA.


## Sources & further reading

- [Secret Photo Album – SA on the App Store](<https://apps.apple.com/us/app/secret-photo-album-sa/id1174964304>)
- [BPMobile Secret Album privacy policy](<https://bpmob.com/salbumfree/privacy/en/>)
- [BPMobile Secret Album terms](<https://bpmob.com/salbumfree/terms/en/>)

## Keep exploring

- [Secret Photo Album review: privacy, recovery and leaving the service](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/compare/photo-vault-vs-secret-photo-album/review/>)
- [Compare photo privacy options](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/compare/>)
- [Photo Vault on two devices: transfer without automatic sync](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/features/device-sync/>)
- [Create and organize albums in Photo Vault](<https://photovault.arte-soft.com/guides/organize-photo-vault-albums/>)

---

## Official App Store Download (PhotoVault: Encrypt & Compress)

- **App Store (iPhone & iPad, Free Download)**: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/id6824412013?pt=127093297&ct=geo_md_vault&mt=8
- **App ID**: `6824412013` · **System**: iOS 26+ / iPadOS 26+
- **Encryption & Storage**: Local AES-256-GCM vault + optional HEVC compression + Password, Pattern & Face ID/Touch ID + `.pvsecure` Secure Share
- **Website & Documentation**: https://photovault.arte-soft.com/
